Our Menu

Pizza

TOPPINGS: Pepperoni, Ham, Ground Beef, Hot or Mild Sausage, Bacon, Onions, Mushrooms, Green Peppers, Black or Green Olives, Jalapeños, Banana Peppers, Pineapple, Anchovies.
*If you prefer thin or thick crust, Please let us know!*

Toppings

Small – 10″

Medium – 12″

Large – 16″

Cheese

$8.40

$11.90

$15.70

1 – Topping

$9.40

$13.20

$17.20

2 – Toppings

$10.40

$14.50

$18.70

3-Toppings

$11.40

$15.80

$20.20

4+ Toppings

$12.40

$17.10

$21.70

Extra Cheese

$1.55

$1.85

$2.35

Extra Thick

$0.55

$0.65

$0.75

Specialty Pizzas

Buffalo Chicken Pizza

Hand tossed pizza with a buffalo sauce base, our boneless chicken wings, and mozzarella cheese. Served with Ranch or Bleu Cheese.

Small $10.15

Medium $13.95

Large $18.70

Barbecue Chicken Pizza

Hand tossed pizza with a barbecue base, our boneless chicken wings, and mozzarella cheese. Served with Ranch or Bleu Cheese.

Small $10.15

Medium $13.95

Large $18.70

All-The-Way

Hand tossed pizza topped with pepperoni, Hot or Mild sausage, onion, green peppers, mushrooms, and black olives.

Small $12.40

Medium $17.10

Large $21.70

The White Pie

Hand tossed pizza with a seasoned olive oil and granulated garlic base topped with mozzarella cheese.

Small $8.40

Medium $11.90

Large $15.70

The Hawaiian Pizza

Hand tossed pizza with a red sauce base, topped with ham, pineapple, and mozzarella cheese.

Small $10.40

Medium $14.50

Large $18.70

Meat Pie

Hand tossed pizza with a red sauce base, topped with pepperoni, Hot or Mild Sausage, ground beef, ham, bacon, and mozzarella cheese.

Small $12.40

Medium $17.10

Large $21.70

Pizza by the Slice – Served until 3pm

Cheese

$2.40

w/ Salad $5.25

1 Topping

$2.70

w/ Salad $5.55

2 Topping

$3.00

w/ Salad $5.85

3 Topping

$3.30

w/ Salad $6.15

4 Topping

$3.50

w/ Salad $6.45

Detroit Style Pizza

16″ Deep Dish

Thick Crust with plenty of mozzarella, your choice of toppings, cooked in a pan to perfection. Covered in Marinara at the END

Cheese (Base): $19.00

Additional Toppings:$1.50

Weekly Special

Tuesdays Only

LASAGNA (11am-2pm) (4:30pm-9pm)

Homemade Lasagna served with Garlic bread.

1/2 Order

$4.50

w/ Salad $8.25

Whole Order

$8.25

w/ Salad $11.10

Appetizers

Boneless Chicken Wings

Wing Sauces: HOT, MILD, NASHVILLE HOT, GARLIC PARMESAN, BBQ, MANGO HABANERO

5 Wings

$4.65

10 Wings

$9.25

Traditional Wings

Wing Sauces: HOT, MILD, NASHVILLE HOT, GARLIC PARMESAN, BBQ, MANGO HABANERO

5 wings

$5.75

10 Wings

$11.45

SERVED WITH CELERY, RANCH OR BLEU CHEESE DRESSING
Wings take additional time

Garlic Bread

$2.75

w/ Cheese $3.45

Toasted bread with our seasoned oil and garlic salt.

Salad

$3.75

Made with Iceberg lettuce and topped with ham, salami, cheese and tomato. Served with your choice of dressing.

Double Salad

$7.50

Our Dressings Include:
Ranch, Honey Mustard, Bleu Cheese, Thousand Island, French, Creamy Italian, Oil & Vinegar, and Balsamic Vinaigrette.

Sub Sandwiches

*White or Wheat Bread, served with deli chips

Choice of:

*Oil & vinegar, mayo, mustard or spicy must.

*Hot or Cold

Italian Meatball

8″ Sub: $7.50

4″ Sub: $4.00

Homemade meatballs smothered with tomato sauce, covered with mozzarella, and topped with stewed onions and peppers.

Turkey Sub

8″ Sub: $7.15

4″ Sub: $3.85

Two layers of sliced turkey topped with provolone cheese.

Submarine Sub

8″ Sub: $7.15

4″ Sub: $3.85

Two layers of ham topped with provolone cheese and salami.

Buffalo Chicken Sub

8″ Sub: $7.50

4″ Sub: $4.00

Boneless chicken wings covered in our buffalo sauce, topped with mozzarella cheese and lettuce. Served with Ranch or Bleu Cheese.

Spicy Sausage

8″ Sub: $7.50

4″ Sub: $4.00

Spicy link sausage smothered in tomato sauce, covered with mozzarella, and topped with stewed onions and peppers..

Roast Beef Sub

8″ Sub: $7.15

4″ Sub: $3.85

Premium roast beef topped with provolone cheese.

Drinks

Pepsi products, Sweet and Unsweet Tea

Small

$1.80

Large

$2.20

Bottled Water

$1.00

Please ask us about our beer selection!

Introducing Our Stromboli Menu!

Barbeque Chicken

Filled with our boneless chicken wings, barbecue sauce, and mozzarella cheese. Served with Ranch or Bleu Cheese.

Small

$9.60

Large

$17.10

Buffalo Chicken

Filled with our boneless chicken wings, buffalo sauce, and mozzarella cheese. Served with Ranch or Bleu Cheese.

Small

$9.60

Large

$17.10

Meat Boli

Filled with pepperoni, hot or mild sausage, ground beef, ham, and bacon with mozzarella cheese. Served with our house marinara.

Small

$11.60

Large

$20.80

The Holy Boli

The All-The-Way Stromboli: Pepperoni, hot or mild sausage, ground beef, onion, green peppers, and black olives. Served with our house marinara sauce.

Small

$11.60

Large

$20.80

The Hawaiian

Filled with ham, pineapple, and mozzarella cheese. Served with our house marinara sauce.

Small

$9.60

Large

$18.00

Build Your Own

You’re In Charge, Limit 7 Fillings.

Small Cheese

$7.60

Large Cheese

$15.20

1 Topping (Small)

$8.60

1 Topping (Large)

$16.60

2 Toppings (Small)

$9.60

2 Toppings (Large)

$18.00

3 Toppings (Small)

$10.60

3 Toppings (Large)

$19.40

4-7 Toppings (Small)

$11.60

4-7 Toppings (Large)

$20.80

Meats: Pepperoni, Hot or Mild Sausage, Ground Beef, Ham, Bacon
Vegetables: Onions, Green Peppers, Black Olives, Green Olives, Mushrooms, Banana Peppers, Jalapeños

Ask anyone around Lake Norman, and they’ll tell you Pie In The Sky Pizza is the best!

Are you ready to enjoy everything that delicious pizza, sub, or boneless wings have to offer? Then you’ll be glad you took time to consider all the wonderful things we offer on our menu! Whether you are serving a family of four, a crowd of 15, or your entire office, we have something that everyone will enjoy for their next meal! Once you’ve chosen your favorite items, let us know whether you’re dining in, carrying out or need it delivered. We know you’ll be impressed and look forward to becoming your favorite family restaurant in town!